The idea that we can and probably should limit our expression of emotion with a partner is directly opposite to the assumed norm that we should always be open and honest and express ourselves fully.
The trouble with this is that it’s just not very relational, in practice.
Picture this: Nicky and Richard have just had their second baby. Nicky is returning to work and her contract has changed, her job now involves a new boss that she is struggling with. She feels micromanaged, is starting to lose confidence in her abilities at work and feels generally irritated.
When venting goes wrong
After a hectic evening getting both of their small children fed and to bed, the couple are exhausted but Nicky decides she needs to vent. ‘I’m so sick of Gary at work, he is an absolute taskmaster and wants to control everything, I don’t know if I can work there anymore. I’m just so sick of it, I really wish you earned more so I didn’t have to work.’ She continues to rant for the next few minutes.
This does not land on Richard. He goes straight to worrying about money, they are barely getting by as it is. He also feels guilty and attacked for not earning more. He feels this is a pattern for Nicky, she has had similar experiences in jobs before. ‘What do you mean? He’s probably just doing his job, he has lots of people to manage! Why can’t you just try and be nice to him? You know how you can be sometimes.’ Nicky explodes and the couple don’t speak for the rest of the night.
After this blow out, the couple struggle to reconnect over the following days and each feels like they don’t really trust the other.
What made it so much worse?
When self-expression is unfiltered, relentless and overwhelming, couple connection becomes the casualty. Renowned US therapist Terry Real describes how ‘offloading intense emotions onto your partner without regulation or consideration—can leave the other person flooded, confused, or defensive. Some people confuse emotional honesty with saying whatever they want, whenever they want, regardless of the impact.’
The damage is destructive – a partner might wonder ‘Is that what they really think of me??’
Self-expression MUST be balanced with self-regulation. Real communication is timely, relational and chooses words that will be heard and support connection, rather than rupture.